All Products

🦃🎄 Limited Quantities. Our holiday rush starts early. Order early for more choices and the best prices. Our handmade treats freeze beautifully for up to 6 months. Learn more.

A pile of golden-brown sugar butter cookies on a white plate, with one cookie broken open to show the gooey middle.

Sugar Butter Cookies

$28.36 $34.04
Holiday red and green sprinkle sugar butter cookies with white chocolate chips, on a white plate

Holiday Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

$28.36 $34.04
Birthday cake confetti cookies on a white plate with rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips. A cookie broken in half to show the gooey middle

Birthday Cake Confetti Cookies

$28.36 $34.04
Military Cookie Care Package - Ships to APO FPO DPO - Butter Maid Bakery

Military Cookie Care Package

$56.73 $68.09
Soldier Cookie Donation - OPERATION: SWEETEST APPRECIATION™

Soldier Cookie Donation - OPERATION: SWEETEST APPRECIATION™

from $1.42
Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll on a baker's scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache Povitica

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Blueberry kolachi roll pastry with fresh blueberries on a white plate, with a rolling pin in the background.

Blueberry Jam Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Chocolate walnut kolachi roll sliced on a marble cutting board. Also called Povitica Potica Beigli Kolache

Chocolate Walnut Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
A close-up of a sliced sweet cream cheese filled kolachi roll pastry, shown in front of wrapped cream cheese package and rolling pin

Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll on bakers scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Poppy seed raisin filled kolachi roll sliced on a baker's scale

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Prune lekvar filled kolachi roll pastry sliced on a baker's scale

Prune Lekvar Filled Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Raspberry jam filled kolachi roll sliced on a serving plate with fresh raspberries, on a holiday table

Raspberry Jam Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll on cutting board - Potica Beigli Kolache Kringle

Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
A walnut and raisin filled kolachi roll pastry, sliced on a white surface

Walnut & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
A clear plastic container holding slices of kolachi roll pastry on a marble countertop

Kolachi Slice Box

$34.03 $39.72
Kolachi Roll Sampler - Apple Cinnamon Jam, Walnut, Poppy Seed - Served Sliced on a Stone Cutting Board

Kolachi Sampler - Apple Cinnamon Jam, Walnut, Poppy Seed

$56.73 $68.09
Kolachi Roll Sampler - Walnut, Apricot, Pecan - sliced on board

Kolachi Sampler - Walnut, Apricot, Pecan

$56.73 $68.09
Nut & Seed Kolachi Variety

Nut & Seed Kolachi Variety

$73.75 $90.78
Buy Chocolate Rum Balls Online

Chocolate Rum Balls

$32.61 $36.88
Gift Card

Gift Card

from $14.19
Chocolate Pecan Kolachi Roll on cutting board - Kringle Potica Beigli

Chocolate Pecan Kolachi Roll

$36.87 $45.39
Sugar butter cookies topped with colorful spring or easter sprinkles and white chocolate chips, on a white plate

Easter Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

$28.36 $34.04
Patriotic Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies - Plated

Patriotic Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

$28.36 $34.04