10/1/25

We Recommend Ordering Now:

Dear Friends,

Fall is here and the holidays are right around the corner. We’re excited to be your holiday baking and gifting partner! With a great selection of traditional holiday pastries and exciting fall flavors, we're thrilled to be a part of your holiday celebrations.

😍 New customers, welcome! Here's a longtime customer secret: order early and freeze. Why? Our holiday season is extremely busy, and because we bake in small-batches the old-fashioned way, we have limited quantities. Our selection gets smaller as the holiday season approaches, until January. You can certainly wait to order, there just won't be as much to choose from. Some favorites are already gone (pumpkin cookies never made it back - sorry!).

The Early Bird Wins:

✅ Plentiful selection of all our favorite flavors

✅ Lowest prices of the season (sales + coupons included)

✅ Gifts that freeze excellent. Send now with a "freeze me" note

Stress-Free Holidays Ahead: Order now, freeze, and sip cocoa while everyone else panics. You’ve got this!

Thanks for making us part of your celebrations. We’re grateful for every order, every story, and every bite shared. 🙏

~ Gloria & Jim (mom & dad), Nick (uncle), Jeff (4th gen), and the rest of the Butter Maid Family