$30.00 Translation missing: en.products.general.sale_price

Peanut butter buckeyes are a super delicious peanut butter fudge ball covered in chocolate. Ours have a reputation of being uniquely better than fudge, a highly addicting soft and moist, creamy treat, with peanut butter packed flavor like no chocolate confection (or other buckeye) you have ever had. No machine produced factory candy here, these are handmade with simple ingredients! Buckeyes are wildly popular in our state of Ohio where they were named for their resemblance to the nut of the Ohio Buckeye tree.

What You Get: Handmade buckeyes vary in size & weight. They're large in comparison to others we've tried at about 1.5oz each, 8 per roughly 12 oz box.

PLEASE NOTE: Buckeyes may become soft during transit if you are shipping to a warm climate. If exposed to heat, the chocolate & peanut butter fudge can lose shape. Neither will affect the quality, simply refrigerate or freeze to make firm again. Small pieces of chocolate can crack off the peanut butter balls during transit in any temperature.

No gluten containing ingredients, however we are not a gluten free bakery and therefore cross contamination is possible.

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Customer Reviews

Based on 238 reviews
Love, Love, Love

Buckeyes are one of my favorite cookies and Buttermaid’s version doesn’t disappoint. They are a generous size so I cut them in ½ to make them last longer.

Terrific food

Love your products


Amazing! Took me back to my grandma’s when I was young.

Debbie W.
Smooth and creamy

The best buckeyes ever! So smooth and creamy. These are a must have! I already ordered these twice so far and many more orders to come!


I LOVE these Buckeyes! They are the best I have ever had! The size is enormous too! This has to be about my sixth order since Christmas! Sooo yummy! I will be back for more!

You may also like