$26.00 Translation missing: en.products.general.sale_price
$22.99

🍫 🥜 The Most Unique and Irresistible Chocolate & Peanut Butter Creation

Indulge in our signature Peanut Butter Buckeyes - impossibly delicious, soft and creamy peanut butter fudge balls wrapped in rich chocolate. More than just another chocolate and peanut butter treat, our one-of-a-kind confections are an addictive peanut butter creation that outshines traditional fudge and ordinary buckeyes. Crafted with simple ingredients, each bite reveals an irresistible creamy peanut butter center that keeps you coming back for more. Inspired by the Ohio Buckeye tree nut, these beloved creations are a regional favorite - and deserve a place on your holiday table, gift boxes, and pantry.

What You Get: Buckeyes vary in size & weight. They're large in comparison to others we've tried at about 1.5oz each, 8 per roughly 12 oz box.

No gluten containing ingredients, however we are not a gluten free bakery and therefore cross contamination is possible.

☀️🍫 Warm Weather Shipping Warning: Chocolate-coated treats may arrive soft or melted - but still delicious! Refrigerate or freeze to restore firmness. Want to avoid melting? - Affordable 2-Day Expedited Shipping is available at checkout. Keep an eye on tracking so the package isn’t left outside in the heat.

Peanut Butter Buckeyes
$22.99

Customer Reviews

Based on 591 reviews
91%
(536)
5%
(31)
2%
(13)
1%
(6)
1%
(6)
B
Brandon

Very sweet but very good

P
Peggy H. (United States)
Excellent! Just one more…

These buckeyes are addictively tasty! Even if they arrive slightly melty, after a half hour in refrigerator, they are perfectly ready to eat and deliciously decadent. A lotta sweetness in each one, so they last longer (until the next holiday gathering!). When they’re gone, I find myself craving just one more…

R
Richard K. (United States)
Delicious

They are yummy 😋

J
Jean B. (United States)
Absolutely Scrumptious!!!

What can I say? Betcha can't eat just one if you are a Peanut butter chocolate lover like me!! I take these to get togethers and everyone ALWAYS raves about how good they taste. I'm sure Butter maid bakery has some additional customers by now.

D
Diana

The buckeyes arrived perfect - at least we thought so. When we.reached in to eat, they were soft and warm… and probably the best Buckeyes my roommate or I had ever had! Seriously! Try a warm buckeye…its amazing!

The cookies were (are!) great. I love soft cookies and they fit the bill perfectly. Sweet and buttery…ill get them again!

Thank you for the fast shipping. Everything arrived in perfect condition and is being enjoyed by all!

You may also like